Cost of Living in Tacoma vs. Puyallup: Which Washington City Fits Your Lifestyle?

Choosing between Tacoma and Puyallup is one of the most common questions I get from buyers — especially military families, first-time homebuyers, and those moving for work.

 Both cities are great, but they serve different lifestyles.

 Here’s the full breakdown to help you decide.

 1. Housing Costs

Tacoma:

More variety, more character, more older homes.

Prices range widely depending on the neighborhood.

Puyallup:

More suburban, more new builds, consistent pricing.

Typically slightly more expensive than Tacoma’s average.

2. Commute & Convenience

For JBLM:

Tacoma → closer & faster

Puyallup → more predictable traffic

For Seattle:

Tacoma → easier access to I-5

Puyallup → longer commute unless using Sounder train

 3. Schools

Generally:

Puyallup schools rank higher

 Tacoma has strong pockets, but varies more by neighborhood

If schools matter most → Puyallup usually wins.

 4. Community Feel

Tacoma:

Urban, artistic, historic, diverse, lively.

 Puyallup:

Suburban, family-oriented, quiet, convenient.

 5. Lifestyle Fit

Choose Tacoma if you want:

• Walkability

• Art, culture, food

• Historic neighborhoods

• Shorter commutes

 Choose Puyallup if you want:

• Suburban feel

• Bigger homes

• Newer builds

• Top schools

• Quiet neighborhoods

 My Recommendation as a Local Realtor

 It’s not about which is “better.”

It’s about which feels more like home.

 Let’s talk through your goals — and I’ll help you figure out which city fits your life best.